Sunday, January 14, 2007

What Dirk meant....

Certain cryptic comments made by Dirk Koetter after being fired have caused a mild stir in Sun Devil Nation. Koetter in his usual guarded self left much room for interpretation when he was quoted saying "The thing is, and I was guilty of this, a lot of people look at ASU on the outside and have this perception of what Arizona State is. And that's not what it is. You have to go on the inside for a while". Some Devil fans were outraged by these comments viewing them as a parting shot by Koetter. While others looked at it as a view to some of the issues that Koetter and now Dennis Erickson face as the head of the football program. A recent article from the San Diego Union Tribune about SDSU recruiting might give some insight into Koetter's remarks. The article and the accompanying chart show ASU as a school that has been reluctant to make exceptions when admitting student athletes who don't meet the normal admission standards of the school. Obviously this practice does not aid ASU in recruiting, but let’s not let Koetter off the hook based on this information. It's hard to make the argument that ASU admission standards are at such a high level that makes them non-competitive. There were much deeper issues that hurt ASU recruiting under Koetter. Too many local and elite recruits reported ASU interest level as mild. ASU was typically a non factor in major Los Angeles and Northern California area prospects. Sure there were some close calls such as with Brigham Harwell, but that was an exception the last 5 years. With many top instate recruits ASU seemed to get in late compared to other big schools. Gerell Robinson a top player for 2008 has already declared to Arizona. Moving forward the question is will Erickson have enough gravitas to affect change in ASU admission policy and in the larger sense will he be as successful in recruiting as he was at Oregon State and Miami.

4 comments:

BayDevil said...

Lower the admission standards...you gotta to be F'en nuts. This is not Stanford. We already admit JC's. Do You want academic casualities that will hurt the program with respect to the NCAA and grad. rates?? Let those kids go to SDSU or Fresno.

Stew said...

I never once called for lowering standards and in fact I think DK using this is bunk. I dont know if you read the chart but the kids arent going to SDSU they are going to UofA, UCLA and CAL on a exception basis. ASU doesn't make exceptions like other PAC 10 schools and it does hurt us.

phillydevil said...

My take was different (although it's certainly possible that Dirk was referring to multiple issues). My interpretation was that Dirk was saying "from the outside, ASU looks like a huge school with huge resources and unlimited potential but that when you look more closely, the resources are actually far more limited." The one thing that I think all Sun Devil fans realized during the coaching search is that ASU does not have the dollars to compete with the big boys. There was no way we could have hired a coach who needed a $1 million buyout and a $2+ million per year contract. Until the alumni starts stepping up to the plate when it comes to contributions, ASU will always be in the second tier financially.

Stew said...

philly

he meant that somewhat oo but I know from sources he was using the fact that he could not recruit certain kids the last few years as an excuse in that story. I think its a legit issue but nearly the reason for his failures. It would be nice if we made the same exceptions the Wildcats make.